Well, obviously Phil wasn't right for this band (well, I'm not sure who is, lol...more later), but couldn't we get rid of another who's clearly not right (Zayra) and keep him in just for some eye-candy? I mean, at least he's cute.
I'm not all that clear on what, exactly, these dudes are looking for, but if it's basically hard rock, then they do have a handful who can do that. I still think Dilana's the best thing I've seen in years, but I would really hate for her to get caught up in a binding contract with a bunch of has beens and stifle her career at all. But then, in all honesty, I can't see these guys choosing a woman as a front man.
I think Lukas or Toby are probably the best suited for this group.
Those guys, btw, obviously are just keeping Zayra in so they can watch her shake her ass some more. I can't imagine that any of them really think she's any good at all. She is constantly going off-key, runs out of breath easily....and her solo last night proved that she really wants the whole Lillith Faire thing anyway.
I agree about Patrice, btw, being too "smiley" (just like Josh) for hard rock. I think she has a great voice though and hope she finds her niche.