MSN Home  |  My MSN  |  Hotmail
Sign in to Windows Live ID Web Search:   
go to MSNGroups 
Free Forum Hosting
 
Important Announcement Important Announcement
The MSN Groups service will close in February 2009. You can move your group to Multiply, MSN’s partner for online groups. Learn More
BUD Inc.[email protected] 
  
What's New
  
  BUD Lobby  
  Conference Room  
  The Offices  
  Results Writers  
  Moves/Matches  
  Site Homepage.  
  Workspace  
  
  
  Tools  
 
All Message Boards : MNH Results .09.22.08
Choose another message board
 
     
Reply
 Message 1 of 2 in Discussion 
From: MSN Nickname_§y©k_  (Original Message)Sent: 9/24/2008 7:19 AM
-Main Event-
Zarek vs Jimmy Stryker

Judge 1
I really liked Jimmy's NC stuff but his rp for the match kind of lacked because his NC stuff was interesting for me to read..Zarek put up his normal quality and at first you could tell Jimmy hadn't even checked the results because he didn't even know he had attacked Zarek...I thought Zarek didn't miss a beat with the attack and played it right like you expect your champion to be able to do..

creativity: Jimmy's NC stuff was more creative to me then really the match stuff by either one

RP flow: Zarek's rps always have a nice flow to them and while I kind of think Jimmy wasn't really into this match his stuff was still decent for the match and his stuff for the NC was really solid

appearance: Ya know for a while I was one of the people on Zarek about his color choices because it did make it very hard for me to read especially being color blind in the first place..He switched up his stuff nicely though and he fixed it which is something I like to see...People sometimes take suggestions as personal attacks and just vow never do anything anyone suggests to them...Jimmy's stuff is usually pretty easy to read and he uses bright colors for his talking usually which helps me out since I have trouble seeing colors anyway

attention to details:
They both set their scenes and they gave you a nice rp , not great rps but they were decent reads
countering:
Zarek did nice with this and he really picked Jimmy apart about the attack and saying he didn't want to be there for Hangover and yet still doing the match

consideration for deadlines: Not a factor that I could see

use of SLs: Jimmy introduced his sister and Zarek played off the attack that I think Jimmy missed at first...I think Jimmy did a better job of progressing his story along but Zarek really don't have a lot of stories going on besides his thing with Gypsy and that was mentioned.

Winner: Zarek Lyle

Judge 2

Creativity: Zareks are the more creative. Jimmy always seems to do the same thing�?whine about the match.

RP Flow: Zareks flow a lot more�?again I feel like I’m reading a novel.

Appearance: I always hated reading yellow tiny lettering. For some reason it gives me a terrible headache.

Attention to details: They both did good�?but since Zarek roleplayed the later of the two his were more so.

Countering: Zarek can sure dish it out, huh?

Consideration for Deadlines: Good.

Use Of SL: Good.

Winner: Zarek Lyle

 
-Match 6-
Gypsy vs. Cross
(With the decision on the Franchise title yet to come and the impending tag title defense against someone laying ahead Gypsy now must contend with the DOA Mastodon...We honestly don't like to see girls beaten up by monsters, it just sort of happens that way and she likes it...that's the fucked up part.)
 
*The announcement of what The Domain is doing with the Franchise title*
 
-Match 5-
Dante vs. DSL
 
Judge 1
I didn't seen why he needed the second rp to be honest but it was funny and DSL just really seemed like she was making the case for being his woman and letting him bag her more then I want to win...If fits their story but it made for a boring match and without the puppet show I really believe this would have been a snoozer.

creativity:
Dante's puppet show was pretty creative and funny

RP flow: DSL had just one and it was more making the case for Dante then I really felt like she was making a case to being a winner...Dante didn't really seem like he needed the second rp at the time but it was a nice humor piece that did give me a chuckle

appearance: Solid rps with no eye squinting or jumbled up words that made me have to cut and paste their work to word pad just so I could see it.

attention to details:
The both set a decent scene but Dante kind of just runs away with a match especially if his opponent just isn't putting in the effort

countering:
Wasn't alot to counter that I could see.

consideration for deadlines: I seen no last minute postings ,though I did notice DSL waited until Sunday to get up her rp before the 24 , which is fine but really I like see more then just that last day posting to beat the 24...Of course when you got outside lives and families that don't always work out that way.

use of SLs: Well Dante said I would like to bang you and DSL pretty much said I would like to be banged...They did stick their SL of the heated tension/lust thing so yeah they did do a nice job in that one.

Winner: Dante Cross

Judge 2

Creativity: Dante seems more creative and entertaining, though I do throw my hat off to DSL. She’s getting good.

RP Flow: Dante’s flow much better than DSL. I feel like I read a novel�?a strange novel when I read his.

Appearance: I dislike the font used on DSL’s rps�?and the light color with it makes my eyes strain.

Attention to details: Dante gets down to the nitty gritty doesn’t he?

Countering: Then ends up tearing them apart

Consideration for Deadlines: Good.

Use Of SL: Good.

Winner: Dante Cross

 
-Match 4-
Kit Black vs White Trash
 
Judge 1
Show stealer match of the evening in my opinion, I enjoyed both ladies rps with Kit's second being her best and WT's first being her best. I think when you factor in both sets though WT's edges Kit's out just slightly in that both of her rps were good and Kit's first one just didn't really grab my attention like a lot of her past stuff has

creativity:
Both girls ran away with this one...WT's is funny and Kit is starting to show that she does have a creative side that I hope we see some more of in her future rps

RP flow: They seemed to flow pretty nicely, I didn't have to go back to look them over to see what was being said or having to re-read because they confused me on something

appearance: Nice solid rps by both, WT's page shift still throws me off at times but I guess that is what sets her apart

attention to details:
Ehh Kit's first one was lacking a little bit but her second set a really good scene and WT's were nice but the second one kind of felt like it dragged to me some, like she wasn't into the posting but just doing it to be doing it
countering:
I think Kit did a little bit better job in this respect but it was a tight match all the way down and I think it shows the stronger female division BUD has developed

consideration for deadlines: Not a factor I didn't think

use of SLs: I'm not sure what either girl's storyline is right now but I think they covered their matches and they covered what was happening around them so I guess if you count that then they both did good.

Winner: White Trash
 
Judge 2
 
Creativity: Kit Black is beginning to step it up unfortunately it seemed that White Trash might have slammed the door in her face. Trash still seems to row with the creativity. Not only are hers funny and very different that what I’ve been seeing as of late it doesn’t seem to get old.

RP Flow: They both flow well.

Appearance: White Trash’s layouts sorta annoy me�?only because her banner never shows. That’s it though.

Attention to details: White Trash can sure pay attention�?but Kit can too.

Countering: But White Trash can sure pick everyone apart.

Consideration for Deadlines: Fine.

Use Of SL: Good.
 
Winner: White Trash
 
 
-Match 3-
Scott Addams vs Josh Drakmen
 
Winner: Scott Addams
 
-Match 2-
Akmed vs Jeffrina Michelle Drakmen
 
Overall one rp a piece and Jeffie's ran away from Akmed's clearly..

creativity:
I wouldn't say either was super creative but Jeffie's had a lot of inclusion of people and also had some SL background there that kind of helped out..Akmed's was just him sitting against a rock...

RP flow: One a piece so you aren't getting the rp to rp flow, but the speaking seemed to go ahead nicely without any halting or either person trying to search for something to say with just a bunch of gibberish

appearance: Neither was hard to read but I would suggest that JMD not use so many darker shades in her talking..Sometimes that gets a little hard on the eyes, but that is just a small critique
attention to details:
Ehhh Jeffie was covering her SL stuff and Akmed spoke of his defeat and they both did set their scenes nicely
countering:
Jeffie got the counter and she did a nice job with it and really ripped into Akmed beating him down and using his words against him.

consideration for deadlines: Not a factor

use of SLs: Jeffie did a real nice job of incorporating her storyline into her match rp

Winner: Jeffrina Michelle Drakmen
 
Judge 2
 
Creativity: Akmed’s were all rehashed. Repetitive. I sorta read the same thing in his roleplay against Faith. Jeffrina’s were the more creative of the two.

RP Flow: I don’t know why but when I read Akmed’s rps I end up reading ten times slower�?maybe its because of the tons of filler words. Not sure.

Appearance: Layouts are fine. No distractions.

Attention to details: Doesn’t really seem they paid attention to either of each. But Jeffrina takes it when the more attention.

Countering: Jeffrina did a good job of this. I can tell she was getting her point across.

Consideration for Deadlines: Good.

Use Of SL: No storyline�?
 
Winner: Jeffrina Michelle Drakmen
 
 
- Match 1 -
Faith Rivers vs Kimberly Caine

Overall I just didn't feel like Kimmie had the time for a match and I question whether she is ready to be back full time with her current work schedule and her family..I might be wrong on that but this definitely wasn't up the par of things she can put out. Faith is turning into a solid talent and I think she is moving along nicely towards a future title shot.

creativity: Wasn't alot of creativity in this one but I did like how Faith's second one opened up and it was something a wee bit different to me so that was a point for her

RP flow: Kim only had the one but I thought Faith's followed a timeline track and you didn't have no huge I'm in Alaska one moment and Mexico the next kind of things so I think the flow was fine and seemed to roll good with the speaking, there was no halting or really vast repeating themselves

appearance: Both rpers were easy to read and told a nice little setting and speaking segments

attention to details:
I liked how Faith's first one had her Mom calling her and it gave a little bit of a backstory for her aswell.

countering:
Faith was the only one with the chance to counter and I thought she did nicely with it.

consideration for deadlines: I didn't think either was late in their postings so this has no bearing

use of SLs: I guess if you take into consideration Faith gave us a little backstory then yes there was some Sl parts to the promos, but not a whole lot really.

Winner: Faith Rivers

Judge 2

Creativity: Faith seems to say the same things with each roleplay she does and it seemed rather refreshing to read Kimberly’s. They seem more well thought on.

RP Flow: They were both good, but I didn’t like the random chit chatting with the parents and then just leaving it off in Faith’s part.

Appearance: They’re both tidy layouts. Not too distracting or anything.

Attention to details: Kimberly takes this�?they had something to say to everything Faith had to say.

Countering: Faith didn’t do so well here. Kimberly just seemed to tear the shit out of her.

Consideration for Deadlines: Good.

Use Of SL: No Storyline

Winner: Kimberly Caine
 
Judge 3
 
creativity: Both of Faith's rps opened up with a setting, her first with a backstory and her mom calling for a job well done at the ppv and the second with her fighting the technicians over the tape. Kimberly didn't give much of a setting, it was just a stand there and look tough. Had she had the time, then maybe her second rp would have been much more creative.

RP flow: Faith followed up what Kimberly had ended. As soon as Kim's rp ended and it was headed right for the production truck to be viewed and possibly even edited, Faith was right there to watch it first.

appearance: I really dont care about layouts

attention to details: Faith's second seemed like she was working off of Kimberly's. Countering Details; able to counter an opponent's dialogue rp with your full attention to complete detail in your counter.
 
countering: Kimber gets this witih the first rp, but Faith slides right in with that second rp. See also Rp flow.

consideration for deadlines: To me it dont matter, you win a match by wanting to win.

use of SLs: Not really.

Winner: Faith Rivers



First  Previous  2 of 2  Next  Last 
Reply
 Message 2 of 2 in Discussion 
From: MSN Nickname_§y©k_Sent: 9/24/2008 7:19 AM

 
:Dark Matches:

-Match 2-
Jade vs Siren
 
Judge 1
 
Overall neither girl's first rp concerned the match and when you put both of their second rps against each other and weigh the critiques I got to go with Jade.

creativity: I think Siren had this one , she did do a couple on the road rps and I kind of like to see people moving around more then just being at the arena so much. I know the wrestlers work at the arena but you don't just magically show up there....So in this catagory I would go with Siren

RP flow: You go two rps a piece and they seemed to follow suit with each other , I mean you didn't have one in the arena and the next in China so I think this catagory was kind of a push in that neither really took a lead in that

appearance: Neither was really that hard to read and I kind of like Jade's opening bits but I liked how Siren was including other people , the only problem was all the other people she included had nothing to do with the match or were even in the second rp where she actually discussed the match..I think Jade's usage was simple yet it fit in that she was getting just rumors about Siren and Jenny and not making out like she knew all that was happening
attention to details:
They both set a nice setting up and I really liked Siren giving some of those minor details that helps you to picture the setting a little better , but I could also say the same thing about Jade, you get the feeling in her words that this is just a lonely girl going through the motions of work because she has nothing else left to do

countering:
Well neither first rp had much to do with the match and Jade got the counter in because she posted last and I thought she did a really good job. I really liked how they didn't need to go to the name calling to make the match and I was impressed with Jade's ability to do a promo and it be solid points without needing to break her opponent down with insults..I mean that works sometimes as well but she cut a solid wrestling promo that I think you would see on any television show.

consideration for deadlines: I didn't think either was late in their postings so no need to mention this one

use of SLs: Jade covered some of her return and being alone, Siren did a nice job of giving a little backstory about her father and such and Jade did a nice job of offering up the fact that Siren is with Jenny and the whole Trannie thing.

Winner: Jade
 
Judge 2
 
Creativity: There seems to be a little bit more creativity here with Siren’s roleplays. She doesn’t just stick in one place and had the tendency to talk about her opponent while still giving it a little push for something different. Jades seemed too old schoolish for me.

RP Flow: Jade had better RP flow�?I like it when it doesn’t sound like a car being slammed on its breaks with each new sentence.

Appearance: Jades layouts are deliciously delightful. Love the banners and the simple layout.

Attention to details: Jade wrote mostly about her opponent. Seeming to take everything she said into consideration.

Countering: Siren doesn’t really say much about Jade in her first roleplay saving just the end of it for a little talk about Jade�?but Jades were all about Siren therefore she could counter with more ease.

Consideration for Deadlines: Pretty good�?not too close to deadline.

Use Of SL: No storyline�? Dark match
 
Winner: Jade


- Match 1 -
 SVD vs Wesley Ray
 
Judge 1
 
Overall I think this match goes to Wesley after laying out the critiques he had more for him then SVD. I think Sal needs to work a little more on his rping technique and not bunch everything together like that. Neither was overly competitive in this match but Wesley's rp was a little better.

creativity: Really neither one was like super creative , at least not to the point that they probably could have been. I think Wesley's was a little more creative then SVD's

RP flow: With only one rp a piece there wasn't alot to flow with

appearance: Wesley's was a little easier to read, I would suggest to SVD that he might spread out his wording and actions a little bit and not have it all crammed together like that
attention to details:
Again you are dealing with two rps and I guess the details were there for as much rping we had.

countering:
There wasn't much countering from SVD because he only did the one rp and Wesley countered that pretty nicely. I think both guys need to really think about stepping up their work when they have their next matches because frankly one rp a piece just isn't going to cut it in my eyes.

consideration for deadlines: No last minute rps here

use of SLs: I didn't see a SL except maybe that this match was kind of a spinoff of SVD calling out Nova...
 
Winner: Wesley Ray
 
Judge 2
 
creativity: Didn’t bore me�?so good.

RP flow: The word structure and flow seems to be a better put together with Wesley’s roleplays. He doesn’t just leave it for the reader to try and have to make out what he’s saying and it seems that with the case of SVD maybe he’s just not having the best time for thinking up material.

appearance: Fairly okay�?I have OCD so the banner and the layout could both be centered�?but that’s all.

attention to details: It seems he had a comment for about everything that SVD had to say. Meaning he really did read the shit in and out of SVD’s roleplays.
 
countering: Wesley did very well in the countering of everything SVD said and then some.

consideration for deadlines: Pretty good�?wasn’t right before the deadline and didn’t spam

use of SLs: Not much of a storyline�?dark match�?/FONT>

Winner: Wesley Ray