By Christie Aschwanden
Migraine headaches slammed into Evelyn Strauss’s life during her sophomore year in college. “I would have to retreat to a dark room for two or three days every time I got one, which was every few weeks,�?says the 41-year-old editor in Santa Cruz, California. “It was horrible. I had to schedule my studying around my migraines.�?She tried several medications, but nothing worked. With nothing to lose, she decided to see a hypnotist. “Hypnosis got rid of the headaches completely,�?she says.
Strauss’s story would not surprise Donald Penzien, a psychologist at the University of Mississippi Medical Center in Jackson. While most people quiet their headaches by popping over-the-counter pain medications or prescription headache drugs, these pills don’t work for everyone, he says. And frequent use of them can actually make the problem worse by triggering rebound headaches—pain that begins as soon as the medication wears off, requiring still more medication and perpetuating the cycle.
Penzien is convinced there’s a better way. He recently published a study analyzing the last 30 years of research into often-overlooked behavioral treatments for headaches, including mind-body therapies like biofeedback and hypnosis. His conclusion: These treatments may actually manage headaches better than drugs. In fact, the real trick to taming headaches is to keep them from developing in the first place—which these mind-body techniques and other alternative remedies can help you do. If a headache does slip through, some of the same treatments can curb symptoms, too.
Whichever therapies you choose, the key is to use them regularly—singly or in combination—as part of a strategy to stop headaches before they start. “Prevention is the name of the game,�?Penzien says.
Identify your triggers
Experts classify headaches into dozens of different types, but tension headaches and migraines are by far the most common, and some people battle both types. No one’s 100 percent sure what causes headaches, but for most people, they’re set off by one or more triggers, which can differ from person to person.
That’s why the first step in a preventive strategy is recognizing what your triggers are and finding ways to avoid them. Common culprits include stress, disrupted sleep patterns, bright light, noise, alcohol, caffeine, and certain foods like cheese and chocolate. (It can be helpful to keep a headache diary, noting when the pain comes on and what you ate, drank, and did beforehand.)
When journalist Lila Guterman, 29, moved to London in 1998, she noticed that her previously infrequent migraines suddenly became regular. “They were often totally incapacitating,�?she says. Thinking about what had changed since her move, she realized that she was making more trips to the coffeepot at her new job. So she quit cold turkey. The first week sans caffeine she felt a mild headache or two, but then they disappeared entirely. “I didn’t get another headache the whole time I was in London,�?she says. Guterman hasn’t gone back to coffee and she rarely gets migraines these days.
Try triple therapy
For Alexander Mauskop, a three-pronged approach is definitely the ticket. A neurologist who directs the New York Headache Center and is coauthor of What Your Doctor May Not Tell You About Migraines, he advises his patients to take a supplement combo he calls triple therapy. It’s a mix of magnesium, riboflavin (also called vitamin B2), and feverfew (Tanacetum parthenium). “All three have been proven effective in double-blind studies and have no serious side effects,�?he says.
Mauskop has published more than ten studies showing a link between magnesium and head pain, and he believes magnesium deficiency plays a role in many, but not all, headaches.
A 1998 study compared a dose of 400 milligrams of riboflavin against a placebo in 55 people with migraines. Over the course of three months, people in the riboflavin group had significantly fewer headaches than those who popped placebos. And a double-blind, placebo-controlled study published in 1988 showed that migraine sufferers who took feverfew had fewer and less severe headaches.
Given this evidence, Mauskop recommends a daily dose of 300 to 500 mg of magnesium (look for the magnesium oxide or chelated magnesium forms), 400 mg of riboflavin, and 100 mg of feverfew for headache prevention.
Before Alice Miceli, a housewife in Bayside, New York, made a visit to Mauskop’s clinic, she says, “I didn’t have a life—every migraine I got lasted 15 hours. Holidays were ruined. I couldn’t make any plans with friends.�?Then she gave his regimen a try.
“It took about three months for the supplements to really kick in, and then it was amazing,�?she says. “I went from 20 headaches per month to maybe two. When I do get them it’s not debilitating like it was before. I can take vacations again. This therapy gave me my life back.�?/FONT>
Magnesium also seems to help with a headache that’s already in full swing. In a study published in the journal Clinical Science in 1995, Mauskop and his colleagues gave one gram of magnesium intravenously to 40 people who had come to the clinic seeking help for an acute headache. Within 15 minutes of beginning the treatment, the pain was cut in half for 80 percent of the patients.
Check out a helpful herb
A little-known herb called butterbur (Petasites hybridus) may also keep head- aches at bay. A study of 202 patients presented at the American Academy of Neurology’s annual meeting in 2002 showed that participants who received a dose of 75 mg of butterbur per day cut the number of headaches they got in half.
Go fishing
If you’d like to try a tasty alternative, eat more fish. They’re loaded with essential fatty acids (EFAs), substances that can reduce the inflammatory response involved in migraines.
Naturopathic physician Todd Nelson, coauthor of Headache Survival, recommends eating cold-water, deep-sea fish one or two times per week and taking a fish oil supplement containing 350 mg of eicosapentanoic acid (EPA) and 200 mg of docosahexanoic acid (DHA) three times a day with meals. Be sure to choose a supplement that’s certified contaminant-free—it’s less likely to contain adulterants like mercury. (With this good thing, more isn’t necessarily better: An excess of EFAs can disrupt normal blood clotting,
so don’t take any more than Nelson recommends.)
Learn to relax, scientifically
Biofeedback couples visualization and breathing techniques with the monitoring of heart rate and body temperature. Its goal is to provide a way for people to learn to track their own physiological responses to stress—and, ultimately, control them. “Biofeedback gives people a sense of control,�?says Mauskop. “That’s important, because it can feel like the headaches are controlling you.�?/FONT>
The key is the immediate feedback: By observing your physiological pro- cesses, you get to see exactly how they respond to your attempts to wind down. When it’s not working, the feedback cues you to focus even more intently, so that you train yourself to relax.
Studies have shown that people who use biofeedback techniques can reduce the frequency and severity of their headaches by as much as 30 to 40 percent. Usually six to eight half-hour sessions are enough to teach people the technique so they’re comfortable using it on their own, Mauskop says. To find a biofeedback therapist, check with a local hospital.
Stretch out
When practiced regularly, yoga, too, can help keep you from getting head- aches. “Yoga is a very simple form of biofeedback,�?says Richard P. Usatine, a family physician and coauthor of Yoga Rx. “You’re using the breath to calm the nervous system. Breathing and doing the poses sends a fax to the brain that says, ‘Hey, it’s time to slow down.’�?
Give acupuncture a go
Kate Genung had her first migraine when she was just 13. “When I got to college, they got really bad,�?she recalls. “I was having migraines for one week of every month.�?When a friend suggested she try acupuncture, which is thought to stimulate the body’s natural painkillers, Genung was skeptical—until she tried it. “The needle releases so much tension,�?she says. “Acupuncture became the highlight of my week.�?/FONT>
Gradually, the frequency, intensity, and duration of the headaches diminished. These days, as long as she gets acupuncture regularly, Genung says, she stays headache-free.
Several small studies support the notion that acupuncture can reduce headache frequency, and there’s anecdotal evidence that it can tone down a headache that’s already in progress. “Acupuncture in the midst of a head- ache can be very helpful,�?Nelson says. “It’s an excellent remedy for muscle tension.�?
Do what moves you
No matter what other remedies you try, don’t skimp on exercise. Mauskop calls aerobic activity one of the best things you can do to prevent and treat head- aches. “I recommend 20 to 30 minutes of exercise five times per week,�?he says. “Exercise relieves stress, improves circulation, and releases the body’s natural painkillers.�?
Try a trance
As Evelyn Strauss learned, hypnosis is another way to teach your body to relax in the face of stress. One study squared hypnosis off against the migraine drug prochlorperazine. Over the following year, migraine sufferers in the hypnosis group experienced fewer headaches than those who received the drug.
It only took a few visits with the hypnotist for Strauss to rein in her pain. “He taped the sessions so I could listen to the tape at home, which I did twice a day for about ten minutes each time,�?she says. “Basically I used the tape to go into trance.�?
Nowadays, Strauss gets a migraine only when she lets one of her primary triggers—running low on sleep—get out of hand. When that happens, she knows she can turn to hypnosis to relax her way out of the pain.
SOURCES
Here’s where you’ll find more information on some of the studies mentioned in the story.
Mind-body therapies
Penzien DB, Rains JC, Andrasik F. Behavioral management of recurrent headache: three decades of experience and empiricism. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback. 2002 Jun;27(2):163-81. Review.
Holroyd KA, Penzien DB. Pharmacological versus non-pharmacological prophylaxis of recurrent migraine headache: a meta-analytic review of clinical trials. Pain. 1990 Jul;42(1):1-13.
Acupuncture
Melchart D, Linde K, Fischer P, et al. Acupuncture for idiopathic headache. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2001;(1):CD001218. Review.
Magnesium
Mauskop A, Altura BT, Cracco RQ, Altura BM. Intravenous magnesium sulphate relieves migraine attacks in patients with low serum ionized magnesium levels: a pilot study. Clin Sci (Lond). 1995 Dec;89(6):633-6.
Riboflavin
Schoenen J, Jacquy J, Lenaerts M. Effectiveness of high-dose riboflavin in migraine prophylaxis. A randomized controlled trial. Neurology. 1998 Feb;50(2):466-70.
Feverfew
Murphy JJ, Heptinstall S, Mitchell JR. Randomised double-blind placebo-controlled trial of feverfew in migraine prevention. Lancet. 1988 Jul 23;2(8604):189-92.
http://www.alternativemedicine.com/common/news/store_news.asp?task=store_news&SID_store_news=857&storeID=02AD61F001A74B5887D3BD11F6C28169