MSN Home  |  My MSN  |  Hotmail
Sign in to Windows Live ID Web Search:   
go to MSNGroups 
Free Forum Hosting
 
Important Announcement Important Announcement
The MSN Groups service will close in February 2009. You can move your group to Multiply, MSN’s partner for online groups. Learn More
Madeleine McCannContains "mature" content, but not necessarily adult.[email protected] 
  
What's New
  
  WELCOME  
  LATEST NEWS  
  PJ FINAL REPORT  
  Member Messages  
  ►►SITE MENU◄◄  
  ►► MESSAGES �?/A>  
  All Messages  
  General  
  Messages For Maddie  
  Madeleine  
  Off Topic  
  Breaking News  
  Pet Memorials  
  MEMBER WELCOME  
  MEET THE MANAGER  
  ►►SUMMARIES◄◄  
  ►►�?MEDIA ◄◄�?/A>  
  NEWSPAPERS  
  Telegraph  
  Newspaper Thread  
  MAY Reports  
  JUNE Reports  
  SUN BOARD  
  TIMES BOARD  
  Daily Mail  
  MIRROR BOARD  
  GUARDIAN BOARD  
  Deleted EXPRESS  
  News Archives  
  News Articles  
  TV Program Links  
  Transcripts  
  TV News  
  Video Links  
  JOURNALISM  
  News Sniffer  
  ►INVESTIGATION�?/A>  
  Interviews  
  Suspicious  
  Re-enactment  
  Subliminal & Propaganda  
  Contrived Abduction  
  Facts  
  'Evidence'  
  Libel Threats  
  Lies  
  Quotes  
  Theories  
  Forged Photos?  
  McCann Travels  
  Timelines  
  FUND INFO  
  Fund  
  FUND INCOME / EXPENSES  
  Fund Compilation  
  FUNDRAISING  
  Fund 'Sources'  
  ►►►PEOPLE◄◄�?/A>  
  Kate McCann  
  Key People  
  Clarence Mitchel  
  Government  
  Brian Kennedy  
  Jon Corner  
  Metodo 3  
  Photofit  
  People MISC  
  Witnesses  
  Family  
  Unknown People  
  Esther McVey  
  Pol. Judiciaria  
  Tapas 7  
  Backers  
  ►►►► INFO◄◄�?/A>  
  Weather  
  The Law  
  Beachy  
  thentherewere4  
  Beachy Posts  
  AMBER ALERT  
  Information  
  M & E Children  
  Statistics  
  HUMAN BEHAVIOUR  
  Body Language  
  ►► CHAT ROOM�?/A>  
  Chat User Guide  
  ►► OPINIONS◄◄  
  Coldwater  
  HiDeHo  
  Jon Gaunt  
  Comments to Note  
  Gerry's Blog  
  Personal Attack  
  Misc Blogs  
  bb2002  
  Tabs poem  
  ►►WEBSITES◄◄  
  mccannfiles.com  
  Website Links  
  ►►PICTURES◄◄  
  Pictures  
  Manager Graphics  
  Pics fo Posting  
  Photo Curiosity  
  Backgrounds  
  ►►FORUMS◄◄  
  Digital Spy  
  Websleuths  
  THE 3 ARGUIDOS  
  3A Thread Lists  
  3A at Brussels Conference  
  3A Smiles  
  3A Ref. Threads  
  3A Distributions  
  3A Leaflets  
  MIRROR FORUM  
  M F Threads  
  Memorable Posts  
  Great Posts  
  Lost Pages  
  ►E-MAIL ADDYS�?/A>  
  ►►COMPUTER ◄◄  
  COMPUTER HELP  
  Computer Tips  
  HOW TO TIPS FOR 3A  
  3A How To Post  
  Avatars  
  ►►�?GAMES◄◄�?/A>  
  Brain Teasers  
  Time Wasters  
  Interesting Fact  
  Funnies  
  Points To Ponder  
  Nostalgia  
  Amateur Sleuth  
  For Skeptics  
  Estelle's Posts  
  Search  
  Priest  
  Remember Madeleine  
  Songs & Lyrics  
  'Source' Info  
  British Police  
  Sheree Dodds  
  PR & Spin  
  Trial  
  Your Web Page  
  3A Here To Stay  
  Documentaries  
  Diary  
  TEAM McCANN  
  Mgzne Interviews  
  TV INTERVIEWS  
  Robert Murat  
  Oprah  
  AMARAL'S BOOK  
  Fridge  
  McCanns History  
  McCann 'Defence'  
  Martin Brunt  
  Statements  
  Apologies  
  Investigate Fund  
  Statement Tables  
  MISC Web Pages  
  Millenium /Tapas  
  
  
  Tools  
 
General : MF Wed Jan 30, 2008- Alleged Censorship at the Mirror Forums
Choose another message board
View All Messages
  Prev Message  Next Message       
Reply
 Message 1 of 1 in Discussion 
From: MSN Nicknametin-lizzy  (Original Message)Sent: 1/31/2008 1:11 AM

Current thread deleted Jan 30/08

Posted: Wed Jan 30, 2008 11:15 pm    Post subject: Re: Alleged Censorship at the Daily Mirror Forum

 



PaulTorremans

This whole issue came to my attention via a work colleague. I thought it was worthwhile following up so I emailed the following to Steven Purcell, The Daily Mirror's online editor. If there is censorship taking place - it does need addressing. But it seems unclear what the issue really is.

I am re posting my email here. I have not received any reply from either Mr Purcell or his colleagues at The Daily Mirror.

RE: Alleged Censorship at the Daily Mirror Forum


"Dear Mr Purcell,
I am a little confused about the Daily Mirror's decision to pull all posts and references to a certain investigation and its representation in the media.

As this particular case is not a pending trial I'm at a loss as to what Terms and Conditions forum users are breaching?

The Daily Mirror to this day portrays and advertises the Mirror Forum as a Public Forum and yet imposes unlawful censorship.

This could very well be seen as manipulating and censoring public opinion, given that the Daily Mirror is misrepresenting the Mirror Forum as a transparent window on public opinion - when it is apparent that is routinely parsed and censured by moderators and admin staff who are alleged to have little or no regard for following the actual Terms and Conditions.

If we were to look at look seriously at Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights on Freedom of Speech, it is difficult to see how all offending posts relating to the case falling under the right to 'protect of the reputation or rights of others'.

For instance, if someone like Colin Stagg had decided to accept an offer of £1 million dollars to his story to the press - the public would have been entitled to vocalise their opinion about its practical and ethical merits.

What forum members cannot do is speculate idly on an investigation, on the individual’s alleged guilt or distribute personal details.

The actual boundaries are sufficiently well defined by law already without having to impose such severe and draconian (and legally questionable) censorship.

Unless there is unequivocal evidence of copyright infringement, profanity, hate speech, defamation, obscenity, issues of security, etc being exercised the Mirror is, quite simply, likely to be violating a number of human rights.

In manipulating and censoring public opinion on issues raised by the case you are misrepresenting public opinion - and it is this that is likely to qualify as an infringement. The Forum is portrayed as an arena in which views and opinions can be exchanged openly but it is commonly alleged that threads and posts are deleted without further explanation from the moderators and serious discussions marred by personal insults and intimidation.

There also appear to be no shortage of people posting comments under multiple identities.

I am sure that Technical Support could look at unusual login and IP activity and find out if any of the above is correct.

Given that the EU has introduced new laws this year to deal with fraudulent blog and forum activity, I feel that the Daily Mirror would be advised to weed out this kind of practice before any formal accusations are levelled.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/t.....361968.ece

Naturally, if the Forum were presented as a specialised Forum for talking about 'Cars', 'Movies' or 'Food' then of course you would be able to treat exceptions to these posts as 'spam'. But you cannot, as far as I am aware, present it as a Forum on Public Opinion ('What You Are Talking About') and unlawfully censor content therein.

I fully accept (and appreciate your efforts) that the issue needed to be addressed and that greater penalties need to be incurred for those wishing to break the Terms and Conditions.

Perhaps a zero tolerance for such posts and more carefully defined boundaries and terms and conditions would have been the more prudent (and fairer) option.

Whilst details pertaining to their guilt or the whereabouts of their daughter should not be under public scrutiny I feel strongly that the media's representation of the case should be under the microscope and that forum members should be allowed to discuss reporting and media behaviour without fear of dismissal.

kind regards,

PaulTorremans