No, sorry Alltims, you can't have it both ways. Credibility problem for your theory here.

 

What you said was, and I quote :-

 

Reply	Recommend Delete    Message 18 of 20 in Discussion
From: <NOBR>Alltimsgotoheaven1</NOBR> Sent: 17/01/2009 18:52 .......This started from him being a Northern Irish Catholic (deny if you like but we all know the truth)......

 

So if that was the truth, then the fact that Anton Rogan was a quieter player and not as good as Lennon is irrelevant. Under your theory, he would have received the same treatment simply because he was a Northern Irish catholic.

 

Except he didn't. Because he didn't seek it.