MSN Home  |  My MSN  |  Hotmail
Sign in to Windows Live ID Web Search:   
go to MSNGroups 
Free Forum Hosting
 
Important Announcement Important Announcement
The MSN Groups service will close in February 2009. You can move your group to Multiply, MSN’s partner for online groups. Learn More
The L1A1 ArmourerContains "mature" content, but not necessarily adult.[email protected] 
  
What's New
  
  The L1A1 Armourer  
  Membership Announcements  
  Message Board  
  
  General  
  
  Open Topic Forum  
  
  AT Weapons Forum  
  
  AK Family Forum  
  
  Bayonet Forum  
  
  Belt Fed Forum  
  
  CETME&HK Forum  
  
  M1,M14 and BM59  
  
  M16 Family Forum  
  
  Pistols Forum  
  
  The Swap Shoppe  
  
  Ask the Armourer  
  
  "War Stories"  
  
  Politics & BS  
  
  Jokes & Humour  
  
  Lest We Forget  
  
  FAQs for Members  
  AASAM 2002 and 2003 Pictures  
  AASAM 2004  
  Pictures  
  Online   
  Member's file cabinet  
  FN FAL links  
  Military/Historical links  
  Militaria links  
  Reference book and magazine links  
  Member's websites  
  Member's Pages  
  Show and Tell  
  Master Gunners AK Manual  
  L85/L86 Forum  
  
  
  Tools  
 
Open Topic Forum : A Terrible Battle
Choose another message board
 
     
Reply
 Message 1 of 1 in Discussion 
From: MasterGunner  (Original Message)Sent: 7/6/2006 7:03 PM

 

The Current Crisis: American Spectator Online
A Terrible Battle
By R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr.
Published 7/6/2006 12:08:08 AM

LONDON -- You might think London a curious locale from which to celebrate July 4th, or Independence Day as we say. But the city abounds with British citizens who admire our country. I spent the evening of July 4th in the vast and glorious edifice that is the English-Speaking Union, observing the 90th anniversary of one of the bloodiest battles of all time and certainly of World War I, the Battle of the Somme.

"July 4th," one of the assembled Brits remarked, "it is the 230th anniversary of one of your happiest moments. Tonight we are observing one of our most unhappy moments, the Somme." Well, at least my interlocutor had no hard feelings about Independence Day, though to hold a grudge after 230 years one would have to be a Serb or an Islamofascist. In fact, as I left the English-Speaking Union I noticed the Stars and Stripes flying from its facade.

What brought us together the other night was a reception for my friend Sir Martin Gilbert's new history of this terrible battle, The Somme: Heroism and Horror in the First World War. The book should be out in America shortly. Gilbert has written 78 books, beginning with his multi-volume life of Winston Churchill. He is the great man's official biographer, and just last year his history of Churchill's long relationship with America was published, Churchill and America. Gilbert is also one of the English language's greatest living historians. So you can be sure his work on Churchill and America is well worth reading. He is also a very great lecturer, and as he prepared a brief lecture for the reception the room was packed, not only with members of the general public but also with fellow historians of note and with Lady Soames, Churchill's surviving daughter. She is a very nice woman, unassuming, quite pretty for eighty or so years, and no cigar clamped between her teeth.

The Somme was misbegotten from the start. Britain's allies, the French, were engaged in a brutal struggle against the Germans at Verdun and they prevailed on the British to mount a second attack on the Germans at the Somme. The British were dug in on one side, the Germans on the other. Prefatory to their infantry assault the Brits laid down a withering artillery barrage. Unbeknownst to them the artillery was not effective. In the respite between the artillery assault and the rush of the British infantry from their trenches and across the open field to the German positions the Germans set up their machine guns. The consequence was slaughter.

On the first day of the battle 19,240 British soldiers lost their lives. More than 36,000 were wounded. The battle went on from July 1, 1916, to November 19, 1916. Ultimately 300,000 lives were lost, counting the casualties of both sides. Twice that many were wounded. Many of the dead were very young, some just 15. The battle, it is said, left a "scar" on the nation. When in World War II Washington was intent on invading Europe, memories of the Somme weighed heavy on our British allies. Even the lion-hearted Churchill urged other strategies.

Martin Gilbert is "an historian," he will tell you, "of the human condition." So in this enthralling history he has quoted from the diaries and letters of the soldiers. He produces many maps and relates the tactics and strategies of the generals, but he also takes you into the trenches with the troops, some of whom went on to great fame, for instance, future Prime Minister Harold Macmillan, who was badly wounded. When Gilbert mentions a soldier who died in battle he adds a special touch. He tells readers where the man is buried, "to enable the reader who might visit the battlefield to pay his or her respects at the graveside." Gilbert is a great student of battlefields and has visited the Somme many times. His knowledge of the terrain is one of the reasons his history is so vivid.

The casualties from war in Iraq are very much on the minds of both Americans and the British today. The death of two British soldiers in Afghanistan over the weekend made headlines here for several days. Thus I was mildly surprised when Lord Watson of Richmond, a distinguished Englishman of impeccable liberal credentials, in his introduction of Gilbert gently put our casualties into perspective. Compare what both of our countries have suffered in this war with what the British suffered in a day at the Somme. The allies did a good thing in beating back the Kaiser and the Coalition forces are doing a good thing in beating back the Islamofascists. At the end of the evening I purchased Gilbert's book and asked him to inscribe it to a pal of mine who is leaving Washington to further serve his country. He is a Marine.


R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr. is the founder and editor in chief of The American Spectator, a contributing editor to the New York Sun, and an adjunct scholar at the Hudson Institute. His latest book is Madame Hillary: The Dark Road to the White House (Regnery Publishing).



First  Previous  No Replies  Next  Last