I didn't know that you folks don't see both shows consecutively..I almost spilled the beans. I actually missed the first half of the season because I'm a faithful "Biggest Loser" fan and it was the same night. Now that's over and I've watched the last 3 weeks of 'Idol'..and like you I cannont believe this kids has gone so long without getting the boot he so rightly deserves. What looks 'dreamy' to the young girls looks like a dork on drugs to me.
On the other hand..the black girl...( I still haven't watched long enough to learn names ) is a real talent and I hope she's the real American Idol. That girl can sing..but she's also got that 'stage presence' too that makes her look professional. So I'm rooting for her !!