1. Theo 2. Mitch 3. Earl 4. Sebastian 5. Katherine 6. Drew 7. Mookie 8. Amberly 9. Mark
My rankings:
Top 9 Rankings:
1. Amberly (9.5/10) - That was magical. Her voice was what sold the song. 2. Mark (8.5/10) - His vocal tonight was pretty good. Apart from the second last note, he made himself one of the stars for one night. 3. Theo (8/10) - Miles better than last week. There's something about him that I don't like though. Maybe it's because he uses a lot of runs in his songs? I think he could benefit from the KISS method and just sing a song straight like Amberly. 4. Earl (6.5/10) - I didn't like the arrangement. The lost note was hideous and made me cover my ears but I really like Earl and I hope he doesn't get cut tomorrow. He reminds me of a better Taylor Hicks. 5. Mitch (5.5/10) - Started off painfully bad. Got better towards the end. I think the song was great for him and he knows how to use his voice to his advantage. 6. Mookie (4.5/10) - I thought this was a poor vocal. He just ran around the stage the whole time singing maybe 3 notes in tune. He still hasn't shown what he can do and sing with his vocals yet. My Mookie love is fading. 7. Katherine (3/10) - Noise, noise, noise. I feel like she's there trying to give an energetic performance but it never quite translates to TV. And I don't think she has a good voice nor does she know how to use it. I think if they stop cramming her into this rock chick, she could do really well. 8. Sebastian (2.5/10) - Better than last week. It was a passable vocal but it put me to sleep. 9. Drew (2/10) - What? Does this guy have some voodoo magic working on everyone? He has a terribly whiny voice and if people are saying Mitch's voice is annoying and whiny, then he is Mitch x 1000. Awful. I will say that he used the stage more this week.
Free Forum Hosting
Important Announcement
First 
Return to American Idol 7