HARRY POTTER, OUR HERO, Part I Big Daddy : so, who's your fav hero? EvonneT.Story: when i had to name 3 i chose Einstein as numbe4 1 Big Daddy: or is it HERO!!!! EvonneT.Story: lol i like HERO! Big Daddy: tres non traditional EvonneT.Story: who is your top hero? Big Daddy: why Odysseus! EvonneT.Story: who hooo! You are well read you even have the book for tonight :) [THE HERO WITH A THOUSAND FACES] Big Daddy: I can really identify with the gods messing with a guy! lol I am a Campbell fan EvonneT.Story: i like the story better than The Book of Job I "get" The Book of Job but geez PAINFUL! Big Daddy: I guess! How are you this evening Mr Cash? the man in black: look there are two of me EvonneT.Story: MIB X 2 the man in black: cool Big Daddy: lol! EvonneT.Story: who is your top hero MIB? the man in black has left. the man in black: awww EvonneT.Story: lol the man in black: don't have one EvonneT.Story: not even an honorable mention? the man in black: it depends on what I am reading at the time Big Daddy: John Wayne? Mother teresa? Ron Jeremy? EvonneT.Story: harry potter? the man in black: uh no yes Big Daddy: so, does the HP series follow the Hero's Path, ala STAR WARS? the man in black: sure seems to EvonneT.Story: I would say so the man in black: it has all the archetypes EvonneT.Story: with the stages of alchemy too Big Daddy: well HP does seem to reject the 'call', but not very hard EvonneT.Story: 1) The call to adventure that the hero has to accept or decline the man in black: he certainly fights against the convention of the powers harry fighta against that too EvonneT.Story: It certainly starts out with the usual difficulty with life for the hero 1.a. the world of suffering or anguish EvonneT.Story: and Harry wishes to escape it Hagrid is a very kewl call to adventure too lol delivery guy of the message anyway Big Daddy: and HP has his Obi Wan the man in black: doesn't every hero? EvonneT.Story: 1.b.When the world is no longer endurable the hero is ripe for the calling That is the formula according to Joseph Cambell MIB Big Daddy: any hero worth their salt... EvonneT.Story: The monomyth Big Daddy: Lucas credits J Campbell for the STAR WARS storyline EvonneT.Story: 1.c. Usually there is some refusal of the call in the beginning According to Lucas, he consciously applied the formula Big Daddy: yeah, what you said EvonneT.Story: lol I really cannot think of a moment when Harry hesitated initially though can you? Big Daddy: just before hagrid takes Harry off in the first book, but HP didn't have to think long about getting the heck out of Dodge EvonneT.Story: then we are still in the formula with the story Joseph Campbell states that our birth itself it part of this call to adventure. that is where we come in ;-) at least at first the man in black: yeah, at his birthday in the shack Big Daddy: MIB is right EvonneT.Story: I never realized that before! the birthday is there too! Big Daddy: only natural hesitancy, a half giant shows up, well come on Harry the man in black: and he continues to hesitate all through each book - he hesitates to conform to requirements of the teachers harry is a rebel hero EvonneT.Story: there is always something at least a little different about a hero what is different about them becomes very special later Big Daddy: The hero, in their adventure, gains knowledge by testing limits EvonneT.Story: not following the crowd is part of harry's strength That brings us to all the parts of STAGE 2 The road of trials 2. Meeting a mentor Big Daddy: "How do you know what it is YOU are supposed to do, if you are doing what everyone tells you you SHOULD be doing" EvonneT.Story: that one is easy in the potter story Big Daddy: Carlos has Don Juan EvonneT.Story: The mentor is an especially sweet element in the Potter story funny in the Don Juan tale lol Big Daddy: Odysseus has Pallas Athena the man in black: he has so many EvonneT.Story: I would say that Dumbledore is the big mentor initially who is like Harry's father he never knew Big Daddy: The others, while passing on wisdom, don't quite meet the Archtype 'mentor' or... mentor for specific situations? the man in black: yeah, I was going to say it is situational EvonneT.Story: who always acknowledges him? Big Daddy: I can't see Dumbledore teaching harry about Quiddich EvonneT.Story: supports him whether he is present or not? the man in black: hagrid EvonneT.Story: secretly sends him a special broom Big Daddy: Dumbledore IS the Prime Mentor tho... EvonneT.Story: hagrid is great and warm big heart Big Daddy: yes the man in black: I think each of them have aspect to mentor EvonneT.Story: but Dumbledore in my read is the prime force Big Daddy: yes the man in black: probably Big Daddy: as per the Archtype EvonneT.Story: he is also the one that seems to see the end picture of where this is going he has the vision hero's make lots of deals, friends, and receive all sorts of help along the way and may have more than one mentor as well Big Daddy: The same character John Wayne played in SANDS OF IWO JIMA teaches his troops to be 'good marines', and then is killed off, ala Dumbledore EvonneT.Story: To me Hagrid simply loves Harry. He helps him out of love. I am not sure of the vision part. I don't feel Hagrid has the vision of where Harry is going. Big Daddy: and Obi Wan EvonneT.Story: Allies Hero's build allies. or maybe allies help build hero's too Big Daddy: Gilgamesh had Enkidu (sp?) EvonneT.Story: 2.b. So crossing the first threshold, the hero gets scared... a stranger in a strange land. Hmmmm Where would that one come in? Big Daddy: one cannot become 'the hero' is one stays where it is safe the hero has to 'exceed the boundries EvonneT.Story: and in the Potter story? Where is the threshold? this one the first crossing Big Daddy: so 'stranger in a strange land' is valid EvonneT.Story: it is in lots of the myths Big Daddy: the boat ride, kinda River Styxx EvonneT.Story: because the hero is with the gods and everything is different Big Daddy: with, or seeking? the man in black: going through the train station Big Daddy: Having a god's support is vital, isn't it? EvonneT.Story: the gat 9 and one-half? the man in black: station 9 and 3/4 EvonneT.Story: oops! Big Daddy: OK, I can see that.... EvonneT.Story: having to plunge yourself through a pillar lol that qualifies as scared sometimes it is just odd Big Daddy: but that is just a taste, the freshman boat ride really sets a tone of 'something different this way comes the man in black: a gateway a between place EvonneT.Story: true going from one land to another is really symbolized there 2.c. Now here is where the friends, allies and enemies are supposed to some in 2.d. along with stress anxiety and a urge to pack the whole thing in the man in black has left. EvonneT.Story: but not only does the hero find dangerous enemies the man in black has left. EvonneT.Story: but people who can help MIB left twice lol Big Daddy: part of the education LOL EvonneT.Story: too bad he is really good at the potter story We covered meeting friends, enemies? allies? Big Daddy: like in the star wars story, HP has allies he never knew existed EvonneT.Story: Now for the cookies from the dark side... as we love to say. :D 2.e. The glimpse of the true, hidden self! something that has been suppressed... denied Big Daddy: OK.... EvonneT.Story: so the horcrux? the dark forest where the spider is? the mirror? Big Daddy: OK! EvonneT.Story: lol Big Daddy: I am hazy on the spider part EvonneT.Story: now that we are so far into this, I am trying to recall the points Big Daddy: Luke when Darth reveals his paternity EvonneT.Story: Luke literally has to "go to the dark side" it is the only way he can win you cannot fight what you cannot understand? Big Daddy: ahem, no, Iraq disproves that notion, one cannot SUCCESSFULLY fight what one doesn't understand who is the guy who has to roll the rock up that hill forever? damn these drugs I am on EvonneT.Story: and lose a liver? Big Daddy: ohhh darn you! no, I think that guy was chained to a rock... EvonneT.Story: Sisyphus Prometheus I am thinking the magic mirror is too soon in the story to be this part and it shows an illusion? The mirror is explained by Dumbledore as something which “shows us nothing more or less than the deepest, most desperate desire of our hearts�?/FONT> Big Daddy: yup EvonneT.Story: for the horcrux, Dumbledore and Harry literally have to enter a cave EvonneT.Story: Do you recall what happens when retrieving the horcrux? is there a time when harry gets a glimpse of his dark side there? Big Daddy: I have not read any HP since the last movie came out, so i am very hazy on HP lore Evonne, I am so sorry, but I must go, RL calls and this was going so well too good to 'see you' again EvonneT.Story: Nighty night! Big Daddy has left. |