scott and chane love the fudge!  i actually prefer the one i messed up lol - i didn't put the final layer on so it's more caramel-ey adn less butterscotch-y.  i like the crunch in the middle. i  like them both a lot though.  i'm going to leave the top layer off the messed up one.  i was very full of cookies when we decided to sample it so i think i'll like it even better tomorrow.  i'm getting sick of sweet stuff right now.  i think i'd like to make a batch with no butterscotch.  i used to like butterscotch but now it's too strong for me and i don't know why.  i used to always put it in my choc chip cookies but now i don't.  in any case, the fudge is still very good!  thanks for recommending it!  scott can't stop eating it so i have to put it away...