MSN Home  |  My MSN  |  Hotmail
Sign in to Windows Live ID Web Search:   
go to MSNGroups 
Free Forum Hosting
 
Important Announcement Important Announcement
The MSN Groups service will close in February 2009. You can move your group to Multiply, MSN’s partner for online groups. Learn More
JANICE'S BI-POLAR SUPPORT SITE[email protected] 
  
What's New
  
  Welcome  
  Your Web Page  
  Words To Live By  
  Intro to Butterfly  
  Read As You Join  
  Chat Guidelines  
  Butterfly's Chat Room  
  MessageBoards  
  The Butterfly  
  The Butterfly Part 2  
  The Cowboy  
  In loving memory of Barb (LadyGhostz)  
  In Memory of Half Pint  
  LovingMemoryPeanut  
  Dear Sweet Internet daughter Peanut  
  The Affective Spectrum  
  Anger Management  
  More on anger  
  What is Bipolar  
  Bipolar Part Two  
  Bipolar Part Three  
  Coping with Bipolar  
  More Bipolar Info  
  Diagnosis  
  Children with Bipolar  
  Useful Links  
  Community Chapel  
  FamousPeople& BP  
  Free Medications  
  Medications  
  Suicide  
  Suicidal Impulses  
  SUICIDE HELP LINE  
  When Panic Attacks  
  Pictures  
  Eating Disorders  
  Self Injury  
  Danger Signals  
  Myths about self injury  
  Treatment-Resistant Depression Pt  
  Treatment-Resistant Depression Pt 2  
  BANDWIDTH THEFT  
  Helpful TIps  
  Sig Requests  
  Your Web Page  
  
  
  Tools  
 
Medical Info. : Causes of Treatment-Resistant Depression
Choose another message board
 
     
Reply
 Message 1 of 1 in Discussion 
From: MSN NicknameTheButterflyJanice  (Original Message)Sent: 3/31/2007 9:07 PM
 
Michael W. Smith, MD, December 2005

If you're coping with long-term depression, you may wonder why you can't feel better. Other people you know may have recovered from their depression more easily -- a few months of therapy or antidepressants and they were back to normal. But it hasn't been like that for you. No matter what treatment you try, you're still suffering.

There is no one reason for treatment-resistant depression. For most people, it's probably a combination of different factors. Some of it is beyond your control, such as the genes you were born with. But there are factors that you can control.

According to experts, here are the reasons why depression can sometimes be hard to treat.

  • Not staying on a medicine long enough. Antidepressants can take as long as six to eight weeks before they fully take effect. Unfortunately, many people -- and sometimes even doctors -- give up on a depression medicine too early, before it's had a chance to help.

  • Skipping doses. If you don't take your antidepressant, it can't help you. You'll never really know if a depression medicine is working unless you take it exactly as prescribed.

  • Unpleasant side effects. Many people who have side effects just stop taking their antidepressants. That isn't a good idea. Instead, talk to your doctor and get some help. You might be able to eliminate or ease the side effects and still get relief from your depression. Also, keep in mind that side effects tend to decrease over time.

  • Drug interactions. Some other medicines don't mix well with antidepressants. When taken at the same time, neither one may work normally. In some cases, interactions could even be dangerous.

  • The wrong medicine or the wrong dose. Antidepressant drugs work very differently in different people. Unfortunately, there's no way to predict how well a depression medicine will work without trying it. So finding the right medicine, at the right dose, takes trial and error -- and occasionally, some time. Many people give up before they find the right one.

  • Your genes. Researchers have found a gene that they believe may make depression harder to treat in some people.

  • Other medical conditions. Some medical conditions -- like heart disease, cancer, or thyroid problems -- can contribute to depression. Other conditions, like anorexia, can too. It's important that you treat any underlying medical problems in addition to your depression.

  • Alcohol or drug abuse. Substance abuse often goes hand-in-hand with depression. It can trigger depression or make it worse. If you have a substance abuse problem, you need to get help.

  • The wrong diagnosis. Some people are simply misdiagnosed with treatment-resistant depression. They might actually have another condition, like bipolar disorder or an anxiety disorder. This is why it's so important to work with an expert.
  • Treatment

    Doctors do not agree on an approach to controlling treatment-resistant depression. Your treatment will depend on your doctor's experience as well as your own needs, concerns, and medical history.

    But while the details may vary, most doctors follow the same basic pattern. Here is a rough outline of how your doctor might treat your depression. If you have treatment-resistant depression, you have already typically failed two or more treatments, usually one or more antidepressants and/or psychotherapy. At that point, your doctor may suggest other options.

  • Other antidepressants. If one type of antidepressant hasn't worked -- or has caused unpleasant side effects -- your doctor may suggest that you try another. This might be a new depression medicine in the same class of drugs or one in a different class. Again, you may need to stay on this medicine up to eight weeks to see its full effects. You'll then need to stay on it for at least several months, depending on your doctor's recommendations. If this second one doesn't work, your doctor may try a combination of depression medicines. Your doctor may also recommend older drugs for depression, such as MAOIs or tricyclics.

  • Augmentation with other medicines. If standard treatments aren't working, your doctor may add other medicines to your antidepressants. The combination can work in cases where antidepressants on their own did not. Types of medicines might include antianxiety drugs, anticonvulsants, antipsychotics, lithium, thyroid hormones, and others. Your doctor may want to try a number of different drugs in different combinations. One drawback is that the more medications you take, the greater potential for side effects.

  • ECT (electroconvulsive therapy). Although sometimes used as first-line treatment for people with severe, life-threatening depression, ECTECT is usually reserved for people with serious depression that can't be controlled with other treatments. It uses electric impulses to trigger controlled seizures in the brain. This treatment can rapidly relieve depression, although its effects often fade.

  • VNS (vagus nerve stimulation). VNSVNS is a new approach used in people with serious depression that hasn't responded to other treatments. Through a pacemaker-like device implanted in the body, VNS delivers regular electrical impulses to the vagus nerve, one of the nerves that relays information to and from the brain.
  • Other experimental techniques. Researchers are working on experimental techniquesexperimental techniques to tackle treatment-resistant depression, like TMS (transcranial magnetic stimulation), MST (magnetic seizure therapy), and deep brain stimulation. These have not been approved by the FDA for treating depression. But if you're interested in trying them, talk to your doctor about joining a clinical trial.

     Lifestyle Changes

  • There's a lot that you can do on your own to ease the symptoms of depression. Changing your lifestyle can have a big effect on your mood. But the problem is that it's not always easy to change our ways. It's one thing to say that you'll exercise five days a week, sleep at least eight hours a night, and eat three healthy meals and two snacks a day. But it's not that easy to actually do. It's especially difficult when you're depressed. The key is to try not to get overwhelmed at the idea of changing your behavior. You also shouldn't try to kick all your bad habits and reform totally overnight. That won't work. Instead, start by making a few small changes to your life. As you start feeling better, make some more changes. Gradually ease yourself into a healthy lifestyle.

    If you have treatment-resistant depression, you may have already tried one or more of these options. Lifestyle changes continue to be important as you and your doctor decide next steps for you. Here are some suggestions.

    • Get some exercise. Studies show that regular exercise can improve your mood and help you sleep better. For instance, one study found that three sessions of aerobic activity each week worked as well as antidepressants in treating nearly two-thirds of depressed people. And after 10 months of regular exercise, only 33% of the people who exercised were depressed, compared to 52% of the people who took antidepressants. The results were published in the journal Psychosomatic Medicine in 2000.

      When you start an exercise program, take it slowly at first. You could begin with walks around the neighborhood with a friend. Gradually, work up to exercising on most days of the week. Try out different activities to find one that you really enjoy. Exercise with a friend or relative or sign up for a class. Doing things you like to do and having other people involved may help you stick with it.

    • Sleep well. Depression, and sometimes antidepressants, can interfere with your sleep. Some people with depression sleep too much. Others can't fall asleep or wake up too early. So get into some good sleep habits. Get on a regular schedule: go to bed and get up at the same time each day. Avoid naps. Before getting in bed, unwind with a good book or soothing music, but not in the bedroom. It might help to reserve the bedroom only for sleep and sex.

    • Eat a healthy diet. There's no diet that will cure or prevent depression. But a sensible eating plan will keep you feeling healthy and give you the nutrients you need. Don't rely on popular diets that cut out food groups and sharply restrict what you can eat. Just focus on the basics: watch your calories, eat lots of vegetables, whole grains, and fruits, and limit fat and sugar. Since caffeine can make you anxious, cut back on soda, coffee, tea, and chocolate. Ask your health care provider if seeing a nutritionist would be a good idea.

    • Avoid alcohol and drugs. Alcohol and drugs can add to your depression and make it worse. Depression and substance abuse often go together. In addition, alcohol and drugs can prevent your antidepressants from working as well as they should. If you have a substance abuse problem, you need to get help now. Addiction or abuse can prevent you from fully recovering from depression.

    • Get some sunlight. Some people find that they get depressed at certain times of the year, most often during the winter when the days are short and the nights are long. This form of depression is called seasonal affective disorder (SAD). If you have SAD, ask your doctor whether light therapy -- exposure to artificial sunlight with a special lamp -- might help.

    • Stay connected and involved. Depression can rob you of your energy. You may feel like you can barely get across the room, let alone go out to dinner and a movie. But push yourself a little. Set aside time to do things that you used to enjoy doing. Get out with your family or friends. Or take up a hobby that used to give you pleasure. Staying active -- and connected with the people in your life -- may help you feel better.

    If you have treatment-resistant depression, you may have already tried one or more of these options. Lifestyle changes continue to be important as you and your doctor decide next steps for you.

    Optimizing Medications

  • Finding the right medication for treatment-resistant depression can be a complicated, delicate process. There is no standard treatment approach for this condition.

    While many medications have been approved for depression, no drugs are approved by the FDA specifically for treatment-resistant depression.

    Still, many people with treatment-resistant depression can be helped with the right medications at the right doses - it just may take some time to find the right balance. It's important to keep these facts in mind:

    • Only 30% of people with depression go into full remission after taking their first course of antidepressants, according to a 2006 study funded by the National Institutes of Health. Those who got better were more likely to be taking slightly higher doses for longer periods than other people.
    • Some antidepressants work better for certain individuals than others. It's not uncommon to try a few different depression medicines during treatment.
    • And some people need more than one depression medicine.

    Work with your doctor closely to try to "optimize" your depression medicines by finding the right dose of the right antidepressants that best relieve your symptoms.

    Antidepressants and Depression Medicines

    There are a dizzying number of depression medicines, and combinations of medicines, your doctor might try. Here is a rundown of some of the categories.

    Antidepressants, in combination with psychotherapypsychotherapy, are often the first treatment that people get for depression. If one antidepressant doesn't work well, you might try another drug of the same class -- which can have different side effects -- or a different class of depression medicines altogether. Your doctor might also try changing the dose. In some cases, your doctor might recommend combining two different antidepressants.

    Here are the main types of antidepressants:

    • Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) are some of the most common antidepressants used for depression. Examples include Celexa, Lexapro, Luvox, Paxil, Prozac (also available as generic fluoxetine), and Zoloft. Side effects are generally mild. They include stomach upset, sexual problems, fatigue, dizziness, weight change, and headaches.

    • Serotonin and norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) are a newer type of antidepressant. This class includes Effexor and Cymbalta. Side effects include upset stomach, insomnia, sexual problems, anxiety, dizziness, and fatigue.

    • Aminoketones, like Wellbutrin, treat depression by an unknown mechanism. It is different than other antidepressants and only weakly affects the brain chemicals influenced by other antidepressants. Side effects are usually mild, including upset stomach, headache, insomnia, and anxiety. Wellbutrin may be less likely to cause sexual side effects than other antidepressants.

    • Tetracyclic antidepressants include Remeron. How Remeron treats depression is unknown, but it does affect both norepinephrine and serotonin, similar to other antidepressants. Side effects are usually mild, and include upset stomach, sleepiness, weight gain, and dizziness.

    • Tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs) were some of the first medications used to treat depression. Examples are Elavil (amitriptyline), Norpramin (desipramine), Tofranil (imipramine), and Pamelor (nortriptyline). Side effects can be severe in some people, which is why they aren't used as often anymore. However, they may help if you haven't responded to newer classes of depression medicine. You may need regular blood tests to monitor the level of tricyclics in your system. These medicines may not be safe for people with heart problems.

    • Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitors (MAOIs) were also an early treatment for depression. Some examples are Nardil (phenelzine), Parnate (tranylcypromine) and Marplan (isocarboxazid.) Although MAOIs work well, they're not prescribed very often because of their side effects. They can cause serious interactions with other medications and with some foods. However, they may help people with treatment-resistant depression that hasn't responded to more common drugs.

    Other depression medicines are often prescribed in addition to antidepressants. This is called "augmentation" -- the second drug can help the antidepressant work better.

    Here are some of the more common medicines that doctors use to augment antidepressant treatment.

    • Some anticonvulsants -- used originally for epilepsy -- may help. Lamictal and Tegretol (carbamazepine) have been studied in people with hard-to-treat depression.

    • Antipsychotic medications like Zyprexa and Risperdal are sometimes used in people with hard-to-treat depression, especially those with hallucinations or delusions.

    • The beta-blocker Visken (pindolol) is often used for high blood pressure and heart problems. But it can also speed up the effects of certain antidepressants.

    • BuSpar (buspirone) is a medicine for anxiety that may help people with hard-to-treat depression.

    • Lithium is one of the most commonly prescribed medications for people with bipolar disorder. It helps level out moods. Studies show that it may also be helpful for people with hard to treat depression. Since lithium is dangerous in high doses, your doctor may need to monitor you closely if you are on it.

    • A synthetic version of a thyroid hormone -- Cytomel (liothyronine) -- has also been shown to help augment the effectiveness of antidepressants.

    • Stimulants like Ritalin or Dexedrine can also help improve the effectiveness of antidepressants for treatment-resistant depression. These medications are commonly used to treat ADHD.

    Tips for Getting the Best Treatment for Your Depression

    • Stick with it. Antidepressants can take up to eight weeks before they take full effect. Don't skip doses or quit treatment early. If you don't take your depression medicine exactly as prescribed, you won't have given it a fair chance to work.

    • See an expert. Any doctor can prescribe depression medication, but a prescription alone isn't the best treatment. You should seek out an expert, like a psychiatrist or a psychologist. Your condition is, by definition, hard to treat. It's important to talk with a trained professional during your treatment. Although psychologists cannot prescribe medication, they are highly-trained in psychotherapy. You can work with a psychologist while taking antidepressants prescribed by your regular doctor, or see a psychiatrist for both your depression medication and talk therapy. Try to find someone who has a lot of experience helping people with treatment-resistant depression.

    • Get in good habits. Take your depression medicine at the same time every day. It's easier to remember if you do it along with another activity like eating breakfast or getting into bed. Get a weekly pillbox, which will make it easy to see if you've missed a dose. Since people sometimes forget a dose now and then, make sure you know what to do if that happens.

    • Don't ignore side effects. Side effects are one of the main reasons that people give up on medication. For instance, in a British study of just over 1,000 people with depression, 65% said they stopped taking their medicine at some point. Of this group, about 45% said side effects were the reason. The results were published in Current Medical Research and Opinion in 2003. So if you have side effects, talk to your doctor. See if there's any way to minimize or eliminate them. However, keep in mind that side effects might be worse when you first start a medicine. Side effects often ease up over time.

    • Never stop taking your depression medicine without your doctor's OK. If you need to stop taking your medicine for some reason, your doctor may want to reduce your dose gradually. If you stop suddenly, you could have side effects and your depression could worsen.

    • Don't assume that you can stop taking your depression medicine when you feel better. If you have treatment-resistant depression, you will need to take your antidepressant for several months -- or possibly a year -- even after you're feeling better. This type of "maintenance medication" can help prevent you from getting more depressed in the future.

    Psychotherapy

  • Psychotherapy - or "talk therapy" -- is an effective treatment for depression. While it may not be enough on its own to resolve treatment-resistant depression, it can play an important role when used together with other treatments.

    What Can Psychotherapy Offer?

    Many studies have shown that therapy can be a powerful treatment for depression. Some, although not all, have found that combining depression medicine with therapy can be particularly effective. A 2004 review published in the Archives of General Psychiatry concluded that therapy combined with antidepressants worked better than depression medicine alone. It also found that therapy can help people stick with their drug treatment in the long term.

    There are few conclusive studies of psychotherapy specifically in people with treatment-resistant depression, according to a review of treatments published in the Journal of Clinical Psychiatry in 2005. But many experts still recommend it. Therapy can help you:

  • Reduce stress in your life
  • Give you a new perspective on problems with family, friends, or co-workers
  • Stick to your treatment
  • Cope with side effects from depression medicine
  • Learn ways to talk to other people about your condition
  • Catch early signs that your depression is getting worse

    Types of Psychotherapy Treatments

    The first step is to find a qualified therapist -- usually a psychiatrist, psychologist, social worker, psychiatric nurse, or counselor. If possible, find someone who has expertise in helping people with treatment-resistant depression. Ask your health care provider for recommendations. Or get in touch with an organization like NAMI, The Nation's Alliance on Mental Illness, or the Depression and Bipolar Support Alliance (DBSA).

    There are many different types of therapy. Here are some of the most common.

    • Cognitive therapy, behavioral therapy, and cognitive behavioral therapy all focus on how your own thoughts and behaviors contribute to your depression. Your therapist will help you learn new ways to react to situations and challenge your preconceptions. You and your therapist might come up with concrete goals. You might also get 'homework' assignments, like keeping a journal, or applying problem-solving techniques in particular situations.

    • Interpersonal therapy focuses on how your relationships with other people play a role in your depression. It focuses on practical issues. You will learn how to recognize unhealthy behaviors and change them.

    • Psychodynamic therapy is a more traditional form of therapy. You and your therapist will explore the roots of your depression. You might focus especially on any traumas of your childhood.

    • Group therapy gives you a chance to talk about your depression with other people who might have a similar condition. A therapist leads the group, which is what makes it different from a support group. The therapist might use any one or a combination of the approaches discussed above.

    While there are many types of therapy, don't worry too much about the approach. Focus on finding a therapist whom you like and trust. Many therapists use a combination of approaches anyway.

    While some people only need therapy for short periods of time, people with treatment-resistant depression might need it for longer. This is called maintenance therapy. Studies show that this lowers your risk of relapse. You and your therapist can watch for signs that your depression might be worsening. Over time, you will also learn about the patterns in your life that lead to depression.

    Trying Psychotherapy Again

    If you have treatment-resistant depression, you may have already tried psychotherapy. Maybe you didn't feel like it worked. But it may be time to give it a second chance. Here are some things to consider before you try again.

    • Think about the reasons you didn't like therapy before. Why didn't it work? What did you need from therapy that you weren't getting?

    • Decide what you want out of therapy now. Do you want to tackle specific problems? Do you want to work through upsetting events from your past? Come up with goals.

    • Consider going back to your old therapist. Even if therapy didn't work last time, that doesn't mean that the therapist was at fault. The experience may be different if you approach therapy with specific goals this time. Going back to a previous therapist may be easier, since he or she will already know your history and situation.

    • Consider trying someone new. It's very important that you like and respect your therapist. If you and your therapist didn't 'click,' therapy is unlikely to work. So you could try someone new. You might even want to meet with a few different therapists before choosing one. Ask about their approaches. Talk about your goals.

    • Give it time. Once you have settled on a therapist, you need to give therapy a chance to work. Don't give up after a few sessions. Like depression medicine, therapy can take a little while before you feel the benefits.

    SOURCES: American Psychiatric Association, Practice Guideline for the Treatment of Patients with Major Depression, 2000. American Psychological Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edition, Text Revision, American Psychiatric Association, 2000. Cadieux, R.J. "Practical Management of Treatment-Resistant Depression," American Family Physician, December 1998; vol 58: pp 2059-62. Compton M.T., "Depression and Bipolar Disorder," ACP Medicine, Psychiatry II, 2003. Depression and Bipolar Support Alliance web site, "Psychotherapy: How It Works and How It Can Help," "Treatment Challenges: Finding Your Way to Wellness." Fochtmann, L.J. and Gelenberg, A.J., Focus, Winter, 2005; vol 3: pp 34-42. Keller, M.B. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 2005; vol 66 (supp. 8): pp 5-12. Pampallona, S. Archives of General Psychiatry, 2004; vol 61: pp 714-719. Plakun, E. "A Psychodynamic Perspective on Treatment-Refractory Mood Disorders," Psychiatric Times, October 2002; vol 19. Stimmel, G. "Options for Treatment-resistant Depression," Psychiatric Times, July 2002; vol 19.



  • First  Previous  No Replies  Next  Last