1. Tommy2Cool - April 25th, 2004
(Tommy becomes the first ever champ after beating Jake Vendetta and BulletProof in a triple threat tables match)

2. BulletProof - May 5th, 2004
(Bullet beats Tommy in a Cage Match)

3. Keegan Fin - June 9th, 2004

4. Xanthus - June 19th, 2004
(then under the alias of Xavier he beats Keegan and Scott Steiner in a triple threat match)

5. DeeJay George - June 30th, 2004
(DeeJay beats Xavier in a Lumberjack match)

6. Alex Van Dam - August 11th, 2004
(AVD beats DeeJay in a Leather Strap match)

7. D-Von Dudley - August 29th, 2004
(D-Von beats AVD in a Tables match)

8. Xanthus(2) - September 12th, 2004
(he is then under the alias of Xavier)

9. "The Jackal" Adam Smith - September 26th, 2004

10. L.A. Jay - October 6th, 2004
(Jay wins a fatal four way TLC match also involving David Blade and Alex Van Dam)

Vacant - October 15th, 2004
(L.A. Jay and Mesa end up departing from SEF, so Jay drops the North American Title and it is declared vacant)

11. The Serial Thriller - October 31st, 2004
(Thriller wins a fatal four way TLC match against Fireproof, The Jackal, and Juice)

12. Derek Helms - December 12th, 2004

13. Scorpion - December 29th, 2004
(Mack then under the alias of Scorpion merges the NA Title with the SEF Title on this same night thus making the NA Title vacant immediately)

Vacant - December 29th, 2004
(declared vacant when it is merged with the SEF World Title)