MSN Home  |  My MSN  |  Hotmail
Sign in to Windows Live ID Web Search:   
go to MSNGroups 
Free Forum Hosting
 
Important Announcement Important Announcement
The MSN Groups service will close in February 2009. You can move your group to Multiply, MSN’s partner for online groups. Learn More
Betwixt the Sea and Sky[email protected] 
  
What's New
  
  Messages and Momentos  
  General  
  Discussions  
  Fun & Games  
  World Care  
  Pictures  
  The Gallery  
  �?Fetch �?/A>  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Treasure Box  
  Bards Bench  
  Sound Waves  
  Inspirations  
  Prayers & Wishes  
  Family Life  
  Smiles  
  Kith & Kin  
  Bards Bench  
  Workshop  
  Recipe & Remedy  
  Documents  
  Betwixt's Own  
  Betwixt's Pick  
  Bars and Banners  
  Backgrounds  
  Gifts  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Kith & Kin  
  Parenting Links  
  Well Wishes  
  Amber Alert  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Wheel of the Year  
  Metals  
  Tree Magic  
  Stones & Gems  
  Animal Lore  
  The Winds  
  Earth Energy  
  Moon Phases  
  Red Hill Valley  
  Kids Stuff  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Library  
  The Bookstand  
  Study Hall  
  Tales & Legends  
  Pathways  
  The Occult  
  Pagan Nomads Dictionary  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Nature's Realm  
  Herbal Applications  
  Herbal Safety  
  Witches Pharmacopoeia  
  Wild Herbs  
  The Healers Nook  
  Weed Wanderings  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Common Ground  
  Religion ~ Timeline  
  Golden Rules  
  Religion of Magic  
  Emergence  
  Eco~Spirituality  
  Pantheism  
  Sacred Shapes  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Chakras  
  Meditation  
  Auras  
  Colour  
  Astral  
  Past Lives  
  Life Forces  
  Reiki  
  Labyrinths  
  Stuff of Dreams  
  Dream Time  
  Lucid Dreams  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Covenant of Peace  
  Desiderata  
  The 3 Worlds  
  The Red Road  
  Yin Yang  
  Warrior's Path  
  Chivalry  
  Brehon Law  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Spirit Realm  
  Apparitions  
  Things that go Bump  
  Haunted  
  Mirror ~ Mirror  
  Spiral Staircase  
  ☼₪ �?�?�?�?�?/A>  
  Divination  
  Rune Lore  
  Numerology  
  A few last words...  
  �?± �?± �?± �?/A>  
  Community Posts  
  Phoenix  
  Re R.Phx  
  Hawk's Own  
  Mah Jongg  
  Badger's  
  Wanduring's  
  Nymph's  
  Fernmeadow's  
  Sidhabhair's  
  
  
  Tools  
 
Discussions : Nature vs. Nurture: Are We Really Born That Way?
Choose another message board
View All Messages
  Prev Message  Next Message       
Reply
 Message 5 of 5 in Discussion 
From: MSN Nicknamesæskwač  in response to Message 4Sent: 1/24/2005 9:45 AM
>> The nature vs. nurture debate reminds me of something I've observed in the
>> offspring of well trained dogs...
 
I would be careful claiming this unless you have some good records and more than anecdotal evidence to back it up.  I have not seen any evidence that leaning can affect the DNA of a creature in such a way that they somehow "pass" the learning down to their offspring, biologically.  There are anecdotes about this, but I've never seen a study that shows it, and believe me, people have tried.
 
There was once a study done on dogs.  There was an ancient belief that docking the tail of a female dog would result in any litters she had after the operation would have deformed tails.  Much to the astonishment of many, even in the scientific community, it was experimentally shown that cutting off the mother's tail did not, in any way, affect the tail growth of her pups.
 
Now, it can be the case that a trait that a trait that is learned by a species effects the environment in such a way that having that trait specified innately would make members of the species more fit.  In this case, natural selection would lead toward that trait becoming innately specified so that the members of the species wouldn't have to learn it.
 
This is known as the "Baldwin Effect", here is a link to a site about it:
 
Now, the important thing to keep in mind here, is that the Baldwin Effect can, indeed, speed up the evolution of some particular innately specified trait, BUT, it's not going to happen in the course of a single generation, resulting in well-trained dogs have innately smart puppies.
 
Now, having said that, your theory about stress causing chemical changes that effect DNA might be possible, but I would be severely skeptical of it unless someone provided some evidence.  Also, considering that females are born with all the eggs they'll ever have through life, I think such a "stress-induced chemical/biological evolution" would probably have to take place by changing male gametes...though changes in female mitochondria could have some effect, as well...an interesting theory that I would definitely like to see further explored experimentally.
 
Cheers,
Sask