The ingredients needed to make the rocks are very evident, so their absence 
had been a major puzzle. 
One theory to explain the omission is the idea that water on Mars has been 
too acidic to allow carbonates. 
The rocks' identification now shows these harsh waters have not dominated all 
parts of Mars - and that is good news for the search for life. 
"You want to get an environment that is basically as clement as possible, 
that's not difficult to live in," explained Bethany Ehlmann from Brown 
University in Providence, Rhode Island. 
"It's difficult to live in a highly acidic environment; it's difficult to 
live in a very salty environment. If you have neutral waters then that presents 
a less difficult environment for microbial life," she told BBC News. 
Weathered rocks 
Ehlmann and colleagues have been detailing the discovery here at the American 
Geophysical Union's (AGU) Fall Meeting 2008. A paper explaining their findings 
is also being published in the journal Science. 
 
The carbonate minerals were detected in a mid-latitude region 
called the Nili Fossae, on the western edge of the Isidis impact basin. 
The landscape viewed by Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) is believed to have 
formed more than 3.6 billion years ago. 
Carbonates are produced in the weathering process that sees water with 
dissolved carbon dioxide re-fashion the original chemistry of rocks. The 
carbonates - in this case, magnesium carbonate - precipitate out of solution. 
On Earth, carbonates are usually associated with great marine sediments like 
limestone and chalk; although the scientists here stressed the Martian 
carbonates would look nothing like that. 
Life hunt 
Previous data from orbiting spacecraft and from the robot rovers on the 
surface of Mars has revealed salt-rich, acidic waters affected much of the 
planet in more modern times. 
Given that carbonates dissolve quickly in low pH solutions, it is possible 
that many large carbonate formations created on early Mars may simply have 
disappeared; and this could explain why it has taken so long to find a carbonate 
signature. 
But the MRO discovery shows that some areas of the Red Planet at least must 
have been untouched by these harsher conditions. That makes Nili Fossae an 
interesting place for future Mars missions to explore. 
"If you preserve carbonates on the surface then you know carbon-bearing 
compounds can survive in some environments on the planet," said Richard Zurek, 
the project scientist on MRO. 
"That means there are some places we can go and look for evidence for past 
life - if it ever existed." 
Interestingly, Nili Fossae lost out in the site selection contest to choose 
the landing location of the next Nasa rover, called the Mars Science Laboratory 
(MSL). 
The vehicle's launch recently slipped from 2009 to 2011 and the scientists at 
AGU said it was possible the contest outcome could now be reviewed. However, 
they also said there would be other opportunities to visit Nili Fossae. 
"MSL is not the last lander that we intend to send to the planet. With this 
diversity of environments, there are many places to explore," said Dr Zurek. 
[email protected]